Rethinking Event Ticket Pricing: Embracing Pay What You Can Models
Here’s what I used to think: ticket prices should be fixed. Set them low enough so people can afford them, but high enough to cover costs. Anything else just felt like chaos. How would you even plan for unpredictable revenue?
But then I helped organize a music and food festival called Eat to the Beat. Held in Austin, Texas in 2022, it was a fundraiser for the Central Texas Food Bank, and we were nervous about pricing. Too low, and we’d barely break even. Too high, and we’d scare off the families we wanted to help.
Someone suggested Pay What You Can (PWYC) pricing. At first, I balked. It sounded like begging. Wouldn’t people just pay the minimum, or worse, nothing at all? But we were stuck, so we gave it a shot. We set three suggested price points: $10, $25, and $50, and allowed people to enter any amount they wanted.
The results blew me away. Yes, some people paid $10. But many paid $25, and a surprising number paid $50 or more. One couple even donated $500 on the spot. We ended up raising 30% more than we’d budgeted, ultimately donating $13,000 to the Central Texas Food Bank. That’s when I realized just how powerful flexible ticket pricing could be.
Why Fixed Pricing Isn’t Always the Answer
Fixed pricing works well for events where the value is straightforward and easy to measure. If you’re hosting a concert by a famous artist or offering a prix-fixe dinner at a Michelin-starred restaurant, it makes sense to set a specific price. The value is tied to the experience, and attendees know what they’re paying for.
But community events are a different beast altogether. These events often aren’t just about the entertainment or goods provided. They’re about connection, belonging, and shared purpose. Assigning a single price tag to something as intangible as community can feel limiting — even inaccessible — to many potential attendees.
Here’s why fixed pricing can fall short:
- Varied Financial Situations: A $20 ticket might be a casual expense for some, but for others, it could mean choosing between attending your event or putting food on the table.
- Missed Opportunities for Generosity: Fixed pricing assumes everyone will pay the same, but some attendees might be willing — even eager — to contribute more if given the chance.
- Community Alienation: Traditional ticketing platforms like Eventbrite often enforce rigid pricing structures. This can alienate people who’d love to attend but simply can’t afford the set price.
When people are given the choice to contribute at a level that reflects their means, something magical happens. Those who can pay more often do, not out of obligation, but because they believe in the cause. It creates a sense of shared investment and goodwill that fixed pricing just can’t replicate.
What CommunityTix Gets Right
This is where the right tools can make all the difference. One of the features that made Eat to the Beat a success was CommunityTix’s built-in PWYC ticketing functionality. Unlike other platforms that force you to set a single price, CommunityTix empowers organizers to define up to three suggested ticket prices. It also allows for an open field where attendees can enter their own amount.
The platform simplifies the process in the following ways:
- Customizable Pricing Tiers: You can set a low, mid-range, and high ticket price, giving attendees options that align with their budgets.
- Open-Field Donations: For those who want to give beyond the suggested tiers, an open-field option allows for maximum flexibility.
- Seamless Payment Integration: CommunityTix integrates with PayPal, ensuring that you retain 100% of the ticket revenue, minus standard payment processing fees.
For events like Eat to the Beat, this flexibility is a game-changer. It removes the all-or-nothing barrier of fixed pricing and shifts the narrative from “What’s the ticket worth?” to “How much can you give to support this cause?” That’s a powerful question, especially for fundraisers.
Why PWYC Works (And Why It’s Not a Free-for-All)
You might be thinking, “Okay, but what’s stopping people from just paying $1?” It’s a valid concern, and one I had myself before trying PWYC.
The reality is that most people want to contribute fairly. When you trust your community to make their own decisions, they often rise to the occasion. Research supports this: a 2010 study published in the Journal of Marketing Research found PWYC pricing can lead to equal or even higher revenues than fixed pricing, particularly in settings where attendees feel an emotional connection to the event or cause.
Here’s how to make PWYC work:
- Set a Realistic Minimum: This ensures you’re covering basic costs while still keeping the event accessible. For example, if your venue costs $1,000 and you expect 100 attendees, a minimum of $10 per ticket could cover your base expenses.
- Offer a Mid-Tier Option: This tier often serves as an anchor, attracting the majority of attendees who want to contribute but may not be able to afford the highest suggested price.
- Include a Premium Option: Frame this as a way for attendees to make a larger impact. For example, “Choose this option to sponsor a family in need.” You might be surprised by how many people opt for the highest tier.
At Eat to the Beat, this tiered approach worked beautifully. Families who couldn’t afford much still attended, often volunteering or bringing food donations. Meanwhile, local businesses and individuals who could pay more treated the event as an opportunity to support their community in a meaningful way.
Adding Technology to the Mix
Managing a PWYC model manually can be a logistical nightmare. How do you keep track of payments? What about receipts? How do you communicate the pricing options effectively?
This is where platforms like CommunityTix come in. The PWYC feature is designed specifically for community events, ensuring a seamless experience for both organizers and attendees. Here’s what makes it work so well:
- Automatic Tracking: All payments are logged in the system, whether they’re made online or at the door. This makes post-event accounting a breeze.
- Customizable Messaging: You can clearly explain your pricing model and its purpose on your event page, so there’s no confusion.
- On-Site Payment Options: For walk-ins who prefer cash or card payments at the door, CommunityTix allows you to log these transactions in real-time.
At Eat to the Beat, this technology saved us so much time and stress. By the end of the event, we had a complete, accurate record of our ticket sales and donations, making it easy to report back to the food bank.
What I’d Do Differently Next Time
Looking back, I realize there’s always room for improvement. While our PWYC model was successful, we could have done more to educate attendees about how it worked. Here’s what I’d change:
- Clearer Communication: Make it abundantly clear on the event page and promotional materials that attendees can pay more (or less) than the suggested amounts. Use language that emphasizes community support and shared purpose.
- Post-Event Follow-Up: Send personalized thank-you emails to attendees, sharing stories about how their contributions made a difference. This not only builds goodwill but also encourages repeat attendance.
- Storytelling: Use the blog feature on CommunityTix to share real stories about the impact of the event. For example, we could have highlighted how the $13,000 raised helped the Central Texas Food Bank serve over 50,000 meals to families in need.
Decision Framework: Fixed Pricing vs. PWYC
| Factor | Fixed Pricing | PWYC |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue Predictability | High | Variable |
| Accessibility | Limited to those who can afford the price | Inclusive for all income levels |
| Community Engagement | Moderate | High |
| Implementation | Simple, but rigid | Requires thoughtful setup & education |
| Flexibility | None | High |
Ready to Try Flexible Ticketing?
If you’re looking to make your events more inclusive while keeping 100% of your ticket revenue, CommunityTix can help. Get started free →
